The Yankees announced following today’s game against the Cardinals that they’ve optioned catcher/first baseman Ben Rice and right-hander Will Warren to the minor leagues. It appears likely that Rice’s demotion to the minors is related to the impending return of veteran first baseman Anthony Rizzo from the 60-day Injured List, as Brendan Kuty of The Athletic was among those to report that the Yankees are “likely” to activate Rizzo from the IL tomorrow. The club will need to clear a spot on the 40-man roster to accommodate Rizzo’s return.
An active roster move like optioning Rice wasn’t necessary to accommodate Rizzo, as rosters are set to expand from 26 to 28 as the calendar flips to September tomorrow. With that being said, the return of the 35-year-old from the injured list seemed all but guaranteed to wipe out the playing time that Rice has been afforded since Rizzo went down with a broken arm back in June. In 175 trips to the plate since then, the rookie has struggled at the plate with a slash line of just .175/.259/.356 (75 wRC+) capped off by a brutal month of August where he’s hit just .057/.171/.057 in 13 games.
Those numbers are worse than even the figures posted by Rizzo in what was a career-worst campaign prior to his injury. The veteran slugger struggled to a .223/.289/.341 slash line with a wRC+ of 80 in 70 games prior to his placement on the IL back in June, by far the worst offensive performance of he’s posted since a 49-game stint with the Padres during his rookie season back in 2011. The Yankees are surely hoping that the decorated veteran, who made three All-Star appearances and posted a 131 wRC+ in his decade-long run with the Cubs from 2012 to 2021, will be able to return to form down the stretch and post numbers closer to the .238/.337/.446 (116 wRC+) line he’s posted since the 2021 season when he first donned a Yankees uniform.
Looking ahead, New York holds a $17MM club option on Rizzo’s services for 2025. Barring an otherworldly performance from Rizzo down the stretch and in the postseason this year, it seems all but certain that option will be declined in favor of a $6MM buyout, allowing Rizzo to become a free agent for the third time in his career. Rizzo’s performance over the next month, now that his broken arm is healed and he’s more than a year removed from the concussion that derailed the latter half of his 2023 campaign, figures to be of great importance to his prospects on the open market this fall.
Also departing the Yankees’ roster alongside Rice is Warren, a rookie right-hander who made his fifth start with the club earlier today. Warren’s first stint in the big leagues ends with a 9.55 ERA in 21 2/3 innings of work, and the righty will return to Triple-A in hopes of sorting things out in an environment with less pressure. Warren’s departure leaves a vacant spot in the club’s rotation, but with a day off on Thursday the club won’t need a fifth starter again until September 10 against the Royals. Warren’s departure creates room for the Yankees to add to pitchers to the active roster tomorrow alongside Rizzo and a second hitter: one to replace Warren and one to occupy the expanded roster spot created tomorrow.
