The Miami Dolphins’ decision to release running back Chris Brooks has resonated deeply among fans, especially given his ongoing status as a free agent following the roster cuts to the mandatory 53 players. Brooks’ absence from the lineup, notably after suffering a shoulder injury and a concussion during a preseason clash with Atlanta, has sparked fierce debate over the wisdom of Miami’s choices.

Brooks, who is yet to be re-signed, brought a distinctly physical element to the Dolphins’ running game—a quality the team lacks without him. His robust running style, although making him susceptible to injuries, was a significant asset when he was on the field. The violent hit he took in the preseason game might be a contributing factor to Miami’s reluctance to bring him back, raising concerns about the severity of his injuries.

In addition to cutting Brooks, the Dolphins have made several adjustments to their backfield. Notably, they re-signed Jeff Wilson and shuffled other players through their practices squad. Anthony McFarland, Jr., briefly returned to the practice squad before being released again, followed by the addition of Deneric Prince, a rookie from the 2023 undrafted class previously with the Chiefs.

Such decisions have led to speculation regarding the team’s strategy and priorities. The absence of action towards reinstating Brooks, coupled with the turnover of other running backs, indicates that Miami might be moving on, prioritizing availability and perhaps seeking a less injury-prone roster.

The Dolphins’ handling of the Brooks situation and their reshuffling of runners point to broader tactical decisions that might be about balancing immediate availability against long-term talent development. However, the fact that Brooks has not been picked up by another team yet could suggest that his medical prognosis might be more severe than publicly known. This scenario unfolds as the Dolphins, along with their fanbase, navigate through the ramifications of their roster choices, which remain puzzling to many, symbolized clearly in the case of Chris Brooks.